Keywords: Powder rheology, flour, gluten, compressibility, flow, shear
RH160
Abstract
Changes in consumer preferences and agricultural practices have resulted in new gluten-free flour feedstocks being used in food products as an alternative to gluten containing flour. Implementation and handling of these powders at scale requires rigorous assessment of the flow and consolidation characteristics. The Powder Rheology Accessory for the TA Instruments™ Discovery™ HRx0 series of rheometers allows for the mechanical characterization of these powders with or without temperature control.
Biodiversification is increasingly relevant in agricultural practices, due to shifts in consumer practices and pressure to offer sustainable options [1]. Flours such as almond, coconut, cassava, and chickpea are made from readily available sources and can reduce reliance on traditional grains, thus increasing biodiversity and offering consumers alternatives [2]. A key aspect of implementing these materials at scale is the rigorous characterization of how the powder’s resistance to flow changes under consolidation; more specifically, how the flow function of the flour changes as a function of upper consolidation stress and temperature. Furthermore, the relationship between the powder shear characteristics and the compressibility can be explored with powder rheology, elucidating how the storage and handling characteristics of the materials change with increased industrial scale [3,4]. Powder rheology plays a vital role in mechanically characterizing these alternative flours, providing insights into their flow behavior and the relationships between these properties. At a deeper level, aspects of the flours relating to the powder flow, shear, and compressibility characteristics can include the particle size distribution, the morphology, level of hydration, particle elasticity, impact of aging, or incorporation of additives [5,6,7].
The Powder Rheology Accessory available for the Discovery Hybrid Rheometer Series has several modes relevant for the characterization of powders with or without temperature control. These include flow characterization, shear characterization, compressibility, and wall friction. All the testing modes, except for wall friction, were considered in this work.

Almond, cassava, chickpea, coconut, and corn flours were obtained commercially from the same brand and tested as received with no additional drying or conditioning of the powders. Testing was performed in a short window of time after opening the samples to prevent time dependent oxidation, humidification, or miscellaneous aging effects throughout the work performed.
Flow Characterization
The Powder Flow Cell includes a helical impeller and a smooth cup. The powder is first conditioned by stirring the powder at a fixed angular and axial velocity, which are related by a fixed helix angle. The helical impeller performs a deformation profile which traces out a helix. This is performed to break up agglomerates and erase the loading mechanical history. Post conditioning, the powder is then trimmed with a funnel. The funnel is then returned to the initial position, resulting in a fixed consistent volume of powder. For the test, the powder is again deformed, with the helical impeller descending into the powder at some angular and axial velocity providing flow characteristics under confined conditions, where the powder is effectively compressed into itself. The helical impeller then ascends upward through the powder (again at fixed angular and axial velocity), effectively characterizing the flow characteristics under unconfined conditions. A TRIOS™ Software method for a flow powder rheology test is shown in Figure 2. Over the course of the test, torque, radial displacement, axial force, gap, and temperature (if using the temperature-controlled unit) are all measured. A plot showing an example of the results from a flow test prior to analysis can be seen in Figure 3.
The flow analysis function performs calculations on the raw measured signals, and results in a total flow energy (confined and unconfined depending on the test setup). In both cases, the torque associated with rotation is integrated along the radial displacement path providing a rotational energy component of the deformation, and the axial force is integrated along the axial path providing the linear axial energy component of the deformation. The sum of these two components is used to calculate the total flow energy for the unconfined and confined portions of the experiment [8,9]. In actual testing scenarios, the powder flowability test can be run consecutively for several cycles to observe any potential changes in flow behavior as the sample is deformed over time. A dimensionless parameter called the stability index can be calculated in TRIOS Software from the ratio of the last flow energy to the first flow energy measurement. A stability index value of one is representative of a stable powder. The stability index of a powder can relate to time-dependent phenomenon under flow conditions such as particle wear, particle breakdown, agglomeration, or more complex phenomena [10]. The flow test can also be performed at different tip speeds to probe the rate dependence of the powder flow characteristics. A flow rate index can be calculated in TRIOS Software. This rate is the ratio of the flow energy corresponding to the lowest tip speed to the flow energy corresponding to the highest tip speed.


Compressibility Characterization
The Compressibility apparatus consists of a smooth plate and smooth cup. The powder can be conditioned in the same way as in a flow characterization sequence to break up agglomerates and erase the mechanical loading history. The powder is then subjected to a list of applied normal axial stresses, a maximum axial stress and increment is specified, along with an equilibration time. A powder compressibility TRIOS Software method can be seen in Figure 4. At each normal stress magnitude, the gap is measured over time until the gap change starts to level off and reach steady state. At this point, the powder is then subjected to the next incrementally higher normal stress and so forth. This can be observed in Figure 5, where the normal stress and gap are plotted as a function of time. After performing the relevant compressibility analysis function, the result is a plot of the steady state compressibility as a function of the applied normal stress.


Shear Characterization
The powder shear measurement is a rigorous test that can assess the changes in a powder’s behavior after consolidation at some upper consolidation normal stress. Depending on powder morphology, moisture content, elasticity, and interparticle surface interactions, changes in powder flow behavior during and after consolidation can be non-trivial. The Shear Cell consists of an upper radially serrated plate that is paired with a cup that has a matching radially serrated base plate. The serration prevents slippage of the powder at the plate-powder interface during shearing.
The powder is initially consolidated using a defined normal or axial stress. Following this initial consolidation, the powder is trimmed using the funnel to provide a consistent volume of the powder. The funnel is then removed and the primary test sequence begins. In this sequence, the powder is first consolidated again at the defined upper consolidation stress, and pre-sheared with a small angular velocity until a steady state shear stress is detected. Depending on the settings, the pre-shear can be repeated until steady state values are matched within 1%. After this the powder is subjected to an alternating sequence of shear tests at a list of normal stresses that typically range within ~20-80% of the initial consolidation normal stress (in descending fashion), and pre-shear steps at the upper consolidation stress [11,12]. In effect, the sample is first consolidated at the upper consolidation stress during the pre-shear step, then subjected to some fraction of the upper consolidation stress and sheared until an incipient shear stress of failure is reached. The powder is then pre-sheared once again at the upper consolidation stress, consolidated to the second highest percentage of the upper consolidation stress and sheared until an incipient shear stress of failure is observed. This process is repeated for the rest of the list of desired normal stresses. A TRIOS Software method for powder shear can be seen in Figure 6. Pre-analysis, a plot of shear stress and normal stress are obtained as a function of time; this can be observed in Figure 7.

The analysis of this data into a digestible form is rather complex but handled with ease in TRIOS Software. First, the steady state shear stresses or incipient shear stresses of failure (shear stress at which powder is observed to start flowing) are marked for each pre-shear step, and for each primary shear step. From this, the average of the pre-shear shear stresses is calculated, and then this average is plotted along with the incipient shear stresses as a function of normal stress. A line of best fit is constructed, which serves as the basis of construction of two Mohr’s circles. The first is constructed such that it passes through the origin and is tangent to the yield locus line. The second Mohr’s circle is constructed such that it simultaneously passes through the pre-shear average and is tangent to the yield locus line [12].


This overall construction then allows for the assessment of the relevant mechanical characteristics of the powder [12,13]:
- Powder cohesion from the y-intercept of the yield locus linear regression
- Unconfined yield strength from the greater x-intercept of the smaller first Mohr’s circle
- Major principal stress from the x-intercept of the larger second Mohr’s circle
- Flow function, defined as the ratio of the major principal stress divided by the unconfined yield strength
- Several different measures of the Angle of Internal Friction
A depiction of this can be seen in Figure 8, where a yield locus analysis has been performed for almond flour (15 kPa upper consolidation stress at 20 °C) with the appropriate labelling. The yield locus linear regression allows for the extrapolated understanding of the mechanical flow characteristics of a powder that had previously been consolidated at some upper normal axial stress but is now free-standing [12,14]. This can be thought of as the mediating forces holding the powder together post-consolidation in the absence of walls; a simple analogy is packing wet sand into a pail, consolidating it, and then dumping it to form a free-standing cylinder.
The Y-intercept, cohesion, is a shear stress relating to the interactions holding the particles together due to a combination of packing, surface interactions, and capillary forces [4,6,7]. The Mohr’s circles act as a graphical tensor transformation that relates the shear stresses to the two components of normal stresses in the system.
The X-axis intercepts are chosen such that the contribution of shear stress is eliminated, and the normal stress maximized [12]. As such, the unconfined yield strength is the maximum normal stress relating to the failure of the powder in the absence of boundaries (and shear stresses). The major principal stress is the largest axial stress component observed within the sample when the sample is subjected to the upper consolidation stress pre-shear steps, but lacking the application of shear stress.
The flow function is a ratio of the major principal stress to the unconfined yield strength. It is a metric of how the axial strength of the powder scales with the maximum normal stresses generated within the sample at a given upper consolidation stress. It is a dimensionless parameter that allows for the rapid categorization of a powder into different categories of flowability: values under 2 indicate very cohesive characteristics, values ranging from 2-4 indicate cohesive behavior, 4-10 easy flowing characteristics, and values above 10 indicate easy flowing characteristics [12,14].
Lastly, there is the angle of internal friction, which is the angle between the yield locus line and the x-axis. The angle of internal friction gives an indication of how the incipient shear stresses of failure scale with additional applied axial stress [12].
It is important to note that all these characteristics are specifically related to the upper consolidation stress. As such, the shear test can be performed at different upper consolidation stress magnitudes (at a given temperature) to observe how these characteristics scale with additional consolidation stresses.
Flow Characterization Results
Two sets of data were generated using the powder flow configuration for the relevant powders. The first set of data is shown in Figure 9, where the total energy is plotted as a function of tip speed at different temperatures (20, 30, and 40°C) for almond flour. Although not labelled, the confined flow resistance is indicated by the spread of large values, and the unconfined by the spread of lower flow energy values. Here it can be observed that the total flow energy is considerably higher in the confined mode than the unconfined mode of deformation. Additionally, in the unconfined mode of deformation, the total flow energy has little dependence on the tip speed. Overall, the differences in total flow energy in either deformation mode have a negligible dependence on the temperature of the powders.
In Figure 10, all the powders tested are overlayed (only one replicate is displayed for visual clarity), where once again the total flow energy for confined and unconfined deformation modes are plotted as a function of tip speed. The flours clearly demonstrate different overall flow resistances, and the differences in flow energy magnitude between samples is most apparent for the confined mode of deformation. In the confined mode, cassava shows the strongest dependence of tip speed. Additionally, in the confined mode, there is a clear hierarchy in flow resistance, with chickpea flour being the most resistant to flow. In the unconfined mode of deformation, rate dependence can be observed for chickpea flour and once again for cassava flour. From a processing perspective, depending on price per unit mass of each powder and formulation needs, it may be more expensive to process and convey one powder over another.


Compressibility Results
Figure 11 features the steady state compressibility percentage plotted as a function of applied normal stress for the five flours characterized (almond, cassava, coconut, chickpea, and corn) at 20 °C. The samples roughly fall into two groupings. In the first group, almond flour and corn flour were the most compressible, reaching a state of ~40% compression at 50 kPa. In contrast to this, coconut, chickpea, and cassava flour were observed to reach a state of around ~30% compression at 50 kPa. A considerable portion of the compression occurs at the first few normal stress magnitudes and then tapers off at the higher normal stresses.

Shear Results
In powder shear testing of a material, it can be crucial to characterize the powder at different upper consolidation stresses to probe how the flow and failure characteristics of the consolidated powder scale with these stresses. This is particularly relevant in hopper design. As a hopper is scaled up, the powder is subjected to additional consolidation stresses, in proportion to the diameter, height, and density of the powder. This additional consolidation can lead to troublesome scenarios, where the powder may fail to feed entirely, or asymmetrically, due to phenomenon such as bridging, ratholing, caking, etc. [9,11,12].
Figure 12 shows powder shear measurements performed on almond flour at three different upper consolidating stresses (3, 9, and 15 kPa) at 20 °C, leading to different yield locus lines and corresponding Mohr’s circles. Notably, the cohesion, unconfined yield strength, and major principal stress of each yield locus analysis increase when subjected to high upper consolidation stress. However, the flow function, or the susceptibility of the powder to flow after consolidation, remains relatively consistent between the three measurements. This indicates that the powder’s tendency to flow post consolidation is left unchanged, making it suitable for scale up. A more rigorous exercise would be to perform additional experiments at different temperatures (still considering the three upper consolidation stresses) to see if the flow characteristics post consolidation change at different environmental conditions.

The same set of experiments as seen in Figure 13 were also performed for the other flours (cassava, chickpea, coconut, and corn) at 20 °C. The unconfined yield strength for each experiment was then plotted as a function of major principal stress, a common graphical format for powder shear measurements. There are additional linear dashed lines indicating the different flow functions (1, 2, 4, and 10) to enable easy visualization of powder flow function regimes. Almond flour and corn flour have a flow function (FF) situated between 2 and 4, meaning they are cohesive in nature at these upper consolidation stresses and temperature. At higher consolidation stresses, the FF of corn can be observed to bend downward to higher values of FF, indicating that the susceptibility of flow increases with scale. Chickpea, coconut, and cassava flours generally have high flow functions. Chickpea can be observed to have an initial flow function that is situated in the cohesive regime, but at higher upper consolidation stresses, it becomes an easy flowing powder. The coconut and cassava flours are both borderline cohesive and easy flowing at the lowest upper consolidation stresses, and then are both easily flowing at the higher upper consolidation stresses. From a dispensing perspective, although the flow measurements were able to crudely probe differences in raw flow resistance of the powders, the shear tests were able to create a more rigorous mapping of the powders flow characteristics and how they scale. One important distinction to make is that the total flow energy as measured in the flow experiment is completely distinct from the flow function. The former has units of energy (Joules), the latter is a dimensionless parameter calculated from the ratio of stresses.
Returning to the compressibility measurements in Figure 11, it was observed that the almond and corn flours were most compressible and had similar compressibility characteristics. From the shear measurements featured in Figure 13, the almond and corn flours were also determined to be the most resistant to flow post consolidation as compared to the other flours. In Figure 14, the unconfined yield strength (from shear measurements) is plotted as a function of the steady state compressibility percentage (from compressibility measurements) at equivalent upper consolidation stresses. The least compressed state corresponds to an upper consolidation stress of 3 kPa, followed by 9 kPa, with the state of highest compression corresponding to 15 kPa. In this plotting convention, the axial strength of the powders can be observed relative to the state of steady state compression.


Flow, compressibility, and shear measurements were performed on a number of grain free (or gluten free) flour alternatives. From the flow measurements, broad changes in the flow behavior in confined and unconfined regimes could be screened as a function of tip speed and temperature. Compressibility measurements were conducted to screen differences in the percentage height difference the powders compressed when subjected to a range of axial normal stresses. Finally, shear measurements were conducted to probe the powder flow characteristics after the powder was consolidated to a defined upper consolidation stress. Although time intensive, multiple measurements can be performed at different upper consolidation stresses to probe changes in the affinity to flow at these different stresses, or at different hopper scales. Powder morphology, hydration level, etc. are critical aspects that were not rigorously considered here. In the case of almond flour for example, the flow function was typically higher than observed for the other powders. With changes to powder size distribution, changes in how the powder is grinded and the resulting particle smoothness, or hydration level and the resulting effects on powder flow characteristics could be quantified.
References
- Duru, M., Therond, O., Martin, G., Martin-Clouaire, R., Magne, M.-A., Justes, E., Journet, E.-P., Aubertot, J.-N., Savary, S., Bergez, J.-E., & Sarthou, J. P. (2015). How to implement biodiversity-based agriculture to enhance ecosystem services: a review. Agronomy for Sustainable Development, 35(4), 1259–1281. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13593-015-0306-1
- Dini, C., García, M. A., & Viña, S. Z. (2012). Non-traditional flours: frontiers between ancestral heritage and innovation. Food & Function, 3(6), 606. https://doi.org/10.1039/c2fo30036b
- Vanarase, A. U., Osorio, J. G., & Muzzio, F. J. (2013). Effects of powder flow properties and shear environment on the performance of continuous mixing of pharmaceutical powders. Powder Technology, 246, 63–72. https://doi. org/10.1016/j.powtec.2013.05.002
- Legoix, L., Gatumel, C., Milhé, M., & Berthiaux, H. (2017). Characterizing powders in order to determine their flow behavior in a mixer: From small scale observations to macroscopic in-mixer rheology for powders of various flowabilities. Powder Technology, 322, 314–331. https://doi. org/10.1016/j.powtec.2017.07.075
- Fu, X., Huck, D., Makein, L., Armstrong, B., Willen, U., & Freeman, T. (2012). Effect of particle shape and size on flow properties of lactose powders. Particuology, 10(2), 203–208. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.partic.2011.11.003
- Shirin Enferad, Petit, J., Gaiani, C., Falk, V., Burgain, J., Kiesgen, S., & Jenny, M. (2020). Effect of particle size and formulation on powder rheology. Particulate Science and Technology, 39(3), 362–370. https://doi.org/10.1080/0272635 1.2020.1738605
- 7. Suhag, R., Kellil, A., & Razem, M. (2024). Factors Influencing Food Powder Flowability. Powders, 3(1), 65–76. https://doi. org/10.3390/powders3010006
- M. Staub and H. Lau, “Shear and Flow Properties of an NMC Based Dry Cathode Powder,” TA Instruments, vol. RH136.
- Barletta, D., Poletto, M., & Santomaso, A. C. (2019). Chapter 4. Bulk Powder Flow Characterisation Techniques. Royal Society of Chemistry EBooks, 64–146. https://doi. org/10.1039/9781788016100-00064
- 10. Mort, P. R. (2005). Scale-up of binder agglomeration processes. Powder Technology, 150(2), 86–103. https://doi. org/1016/j.powtec.2004.11.025
- Aulton, M. E., & Taylor, K. (2018). Aulton’s pharmaceutics : The design and manufacture of medicines (5th ed.). Elsevier.
- Mariano, M. (2024). General aspects of powder rheology applied to pharmaceutical formulations. Drug Discovery Today, 29(5), 103976. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.drudis.2024.103976
- Brubaker, J., & Moghtadernejad, S. (2024). A Comprehensive Review of the Rheological Properties of Powders in Pharmaceuticals. Powders, 3(2), 233–254. https://doi. org/10.3390/powders3020015
- Neikov, O. D., Lotsko, D. V., & Gopienko, V. G. (2009). Powder characterization and testing. Handbook of non-ferrous metal powders, 2.
Acknowledgement
For more information or to request a product quote, please visit www.tainstruments.com to locate your local sales office information.
This paper was written by Keith Coasey, Ph.D.
TA Instruments, Discovery, and TRIOS are trademarks of Waters Corporation or its affiliates.
Click here to download the printable version of this application note.
